Why in News?
The reported ‘purification’ ritual in Uttarakhand in August 2026, following a rally addressed by Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge, a Dalit leader, reignited debate over caste-based notions of purity and pollution.
The incident triggered debate over the persistence of caste-based notions of purity and pollution despite Article 17 of the Constitution abolishing untouchability.
It has renewed questions about the effectiveness of existing laws, enforcement mechanisms and the need for social reform to eliminate caste discrimination.
Constitutional and Legal Framework
Article 17: Abolishes untouchability in all forms
- The Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955, penalises its enforcement.
- Example: Article 17 provides the constitutional basis for challenging caste-based exclusion from public facilities.
Articles 14, 15 and 21: Guarantee equality, prohibit specified forms of discrimination and protect life and dignity.
Article 46: Directs the State to protect weaker sections, particularly SCs and STs, from social injustice and exploitation.
SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989: Provides legal remedies, special courts and victim-relief measures for specified atrocities.
Manual Scavengers Act, 2013: Prohibits employment as manual scavengers and provides for rehabilitation.
Why Legal Guarantees Alone Are Insufficient
Entrenched social conditioning: Caste hierarchy persists through inherited notions of purity and pollution.
- Example: Separate utensils for Dalit guests in some social settings.
Retaliation against mobility: Dalit assertion can provoke backlash from dominant groups.
- Example: Threats or social boycotts against individuals challenging caste hierarchies.
Weak enforcement: Delayed investigations, victim intimidation and inadequate prosecution undermine deterrence.
- NCRB’s Crime in India publications document continuing registered offences against Scheduled Castes.
Underreporting: Economic dependence and fear of retaliation discourage complaints.
- Inference: Registered cases cannot capture the entire prevalence of discrimination.
Social segregation: Residential separation and caste endogamy limit social interaction.
- Example: Separate Dalit hamlets and unequal access to common water facilities.
Evidence: The India Human Development Survey (IHDS), 2011-12, found that approximately 27% of respondents reported practising untouchability. This is historical evidence, not a current prevalence estimate.
Achievements and Emerging Challenges
Reduced overt exclusion: Constitutional safeguards challenge denial of access to public wells, educational institutions and other public facilities.
Enhanced social mobility: Reservations have widened access to education, public employment and political representation, although discrimination persists.
Institutional discrimination: In Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India (2024), the Supreme Court struck down caste-discriminatory provisions in prison manuals.
Continuing atrocities: NCRB data recorded 53,372 cases of crimes against Scheduled Castes in 2023, compared with 45,995 in 2020. These figures indicate continuing registered offences but do not independently establish a proportional rise in actual incidence.
Institutional Accountability and Wider Evidence
Judicial accountability: Timely trials, witness protection and effective prosecution are essential to enforce statutory safeguards.
NCSC oversight: The National Commission for Scheduled Castes, under Article 338, investigates complaints and monitors constitutional protections.
International scrutiny: The UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination has raised concerns about caste-based discrimination, segregation and barriers to justice.
- India maintains that caste is distinct from race, while the Committee considers descent-based discrimination within its mandate.
Data limitations: NCRB recorded 24 cases under the Protection of Civil Rights Act in 2023. This narrow category does not measure the total prevalence of untouchability because related offences may be registered under other laws.
Way Forward
Strengthen enforcement: Improve investigation, legal aid, victim rehabilitation and compliance with statutory safeguards.
Reform education: Revise textbooks and train teachers to challenge caste stereotypes and promote constitutional morality.
Ensure common access: Guarantee equal access to Anganwadis, schools, drinking-water facilities and community centres through inclusive planning.
Promote social integration: Encourage inter-caste interaction and voluntary inter-caste marriages while protecting individual autonomy.
Expand remedies: Develop accessible civil remedies against discriminatory denial of housing, education and services alongside criminal prosecution.
Monitor outcomes: Combine NCRB statistics with surveys of discrimination, access to public services and victim experiences.





