Why in News?
The Election Commission of India (ECI), under Article 324 of the Constitution, supervises elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of the President and Vice-President.
Former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa highlights controversies surrounding electoral-roll revisions, Forms 6 and 7, alleged partisan conduct and centralised data management.
These concerns raise questions about the ECI’s independence, transparency and ability to safeguard electoral integrity.
Forms 6 and 7: Legal and Procedural Concerns
Form 6 controversy: Used for inclusion in electoral rolls, Form 6 was accompanied by an additional declaration during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) announced on June 24, 2025.
- This bring questions on whether the additional documentary requirements complied with the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
Statutory authority: Section 28 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, empowers the Central Government to make rules under the Act.
- The controversy concerns whether the ECI could introduce additional requirements through an administrative notification.
Citizenship verification: The Supreme Court’s May 27, 2026, judgment concerning Bihar’s SIR addressed the ECI’s authority to verify citizenship-related eligibility while distinguishing electoral registration from final citizenship adjudication.
Form 7 misuse: There is allegation of bulk objections against existing voters in Uttarakhand, Karnataka and other States.
- Failure to investigate fraudulent objections risks wrongful deletion and disenfranchisement.
Institutional Independence and Transparency Deficits
Appointment concerns: The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023, replaced the Chief Justice of India with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister on the selection committee, raising concerns about executive influence.
Judicial precedent: In Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court prescribed an interim appointment mechanism involving the Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition and Chief Justice of India until Parliament enacted a law.
MCC enforcement: Lavasa alleges inconsistent action against political leaders during the 2019 and 2024 general elections.
- Selective enforcement, if established, would undermine the electoral level playing field.
Disclosure restrictions: December 2024 amendment to election-related document-sharing rules following a Punjab and Haryana High Court order concerning disclosure, particularly access to polling footage.
Internal accountability: The Indian Express reported that Election Commissioners had raised internal concerns over Form 6 and software access.
- Such reports warrant scrutiny but do not independently establish deliberate manipulation.
SIR, Digital Governance and Democratic Consequences
Large-scale revision: Phase II of the SIR covered nine States and three Union Territories, encompassing nearly 51 crore electors.
West Bengal example: According to the ECI’s reported submission, 27.16 lakh voters were deleted during the SIR, while 22.21 lakh appeals sought restoration and 16.10 lakh sought further deletions, highlighting the scale of disputes.
Vulnerable electors: Migrant workers, homeless citizens and elderly persons may face difficulties with documentation and house-to-house verification, increasing the risk of wrongful exclusion.
Technology concerns: Reported complaints from Electoral Registration Officers in Goa and West Bengal, alongside concerns raised by appellate tribunal judges, indicate possible technical barriers to statutory decision-making.
Constitutional implications: Article 326 provides for adult suffrage subject to prescribed qualifications, while Article 14 guards against arbitrary state action. Erroneous deletions and opaque procedures can undermine both electoral participation and public trust.
Way Forward: Institutional and Electoral Reforms
Ensure legal compliance: Modify electoral forms only through the prescribed legal process, with clear statutory justification and appropriate judicial scrutiny.
Safeguard voters: Provide individual notice, an opportunity to respond, accessible appeals and multilingual assistance before consequential deletions.
Prevent misuse: Publish disaggregated Form 7 objection statistics and investigate suspected fraudulent or coordinated applications.
Audit digital systems: Maintain tamper-evident logs, independent software audits and role-based access while preserving Electoral Registration Officers’ statutory decision-making authority.
Strengthen independence: Improve appointment transparency and ensure consistent, reasoned enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct.
Enhance accountability: Publish anonymised revision data and explain disputed decisions while protecting personal information, thereby strengthening public confidence in electoral administration.





